You’re attempting to view exclusive content only for members in the __tier_name__.
Already have an account? Sign in
You’re attempting to view exclusive content only for members in the __tier_name__.
Already have an account? Sign in
Last updated: Sep 21, 2025
...And why thousands of men are rushing to grab the #1 box of 2025 before it’s gone.
Written by: Mark DiGiovanni
Published on: Dec 17, 2024
(Los Angeles) For men over 35, we're getting pounded with ads for meat delivery services.
But with so many options now how do you know which is actually delivering on the "better than the grocery store" promise they all seem to make?
I subscribed to all of them and broke down my ranking for you. Number 1 was a HUGE SHOCK.
The Meatery
Our readers get up to a 20% discount!
Omaha Steaks is the granddaddy of mail-order meat, known for fancy gift boxes and decades in business. However, many longtime customers say it’s turned into an overpriced nostalgia act – decent steaks overshadowed by steep prices, upsells, and tiny portions. It’s a household name, sure, but today Omaha’s once-premium offerings feel ordinary. Bottom line: a classic brand that no longer lives up to the hype for modern meat lovers.
Crowd Cow made waves by connecting people directly with small farms and specialty beef (even offering coveted Japanese Wagyu cuts). It’s a cool concept for those who want to know exactly where their meat comes from. However, that farm-to-table artistry comes at a cost – and it can drain your wallet fast. The a la carte ordering and boutique prices turn off guys who just want a convenient subscription. It’s a niche indulgence for sure, but not the best bang for your buck if you crave value and flavor in one simple box.
Source: Crowd Cow
Moink Box won hearts on Shark Tank by championing small family farms and “ethical meat” – think grass-fed beef, pasture-raised pork, wild-caught salmon. Supporting American farmers and cleaner meat is great. However, at roughly $159 a box, you’re paying a premium for principle more than mind-blowing taste. The cuts themselves are fine but fairly basic, and some customers report the flavor just doesn’t wow. It’s ideal if you prioritize farming ethics over filet mignon, but for the price point, most men expect a bit more excitement on their plate.
Source: Moink
ButcherBox is the heavyweight champ of meat subscriptions in terms of popularity. They deliver grass-fed beef and organic chicken to thousands of doorsteps, and it’s undeniably convenient. Many folks trust the brand for staple proteins. However, loyalty only goes so far – and plenty of subscribers admit the actual taste is nothing special (on par with supermarket cuts). You won’t find ultra-marbled Wagyu or adventurous game meats here; it’s the same basic cuts everyone else sells. And with plans hovering around steakhouse money ($150+ per month), some feel they’re paying top dollar for grocery-level meat. ButcherBox might have been #1 a few years ago, but today it feels basic and overpriced next to the new king on the block.
Source: Butcher Box
See why butchers, chefs, and health-savvy dads alike are calling this the #1 meat subscription for 2025 – and learn how you can fill your freezer with restaurant-grade cuts (yes, even melt-in-your-mouth Wagyu) at a fraction of the cost of other boxes. This upstart service delivers accessible luxury: ultra-premium beef without the insane markup. They even let you build your own box of hand-picked meats, so you get exactly what you crave each month.
Oh...and you get a FREE Piece of Japanese A5 Wagyu when you sign up!
