Wagyu 101

Why Australian Wagyu is Worth the Splurge: A Comparative Study with Other Premium Meats

By Nicholas Fiorentino

When it comes to premium meats, few can rival the indulgent taste and buttery texture of Wagyu beef. Originally from Japan, this breed of cattle has been carefully cultivated for centuries, resulting in highly marbled and tenderized meat.

However, with the rising popularity of Wagyu beef, other countries have begun to produce their version of this premium meat, including Australia. In this article, we'll explore what makes Australian Wagyu so special, how it compares to other premium meats, and offer tips on how to cook it to perfection.

Is Australian Wagyu real Wagyu? 

One common question that comes up when discussing Australian Wagyu is whether it is "real" Wagyu. The answer is yes and no. While the breed of cattle used to produce Australian Wagyu is the same as that used in Japan, the cattle are not necessarily raised or fed in the same way.

In Japan, Wagyu cattle are fed a specialized diet and raised in specific conditions that result in the high levels of marbling and tenderness that the meat is known for. In Australia, however, the conditions are different.

The meat may not have the same level of marbling or flavor as Japanese Wagyu. That being said, Australian Wagyu is still considered to be a high-quality meat and is often used in top-tier restaurants around the world.

Why is Australian Wagyu so expensive? 

The amount of time and effort that goes into raising cattle is one of the main reasons why Australian Wagyu is so expensive. The cattle are typically raised for longer periods than other breeds, allowing for more intramuscular fat to develop, which leads to the characteristic marbling of Wagyu beef. For example, a luxurious cut like the Filet Mignon or a shareable Tomahawk steak exemplifies this rich marbling, making them particularly prized and thus more costly.

Additionally, the cost of feed for these cattle is often higher than that of other breeds, as they require a specialized diet that includes high-quality grains and other supplements. Finally, because Australian Wagyu is often considered to be a luxury product, it commands a higher price on the market.

Is Australian Wagyu better than American? 

When comparing Australian Wagyu to American Wagyu, there are some differences to consider. While both types of meat come from the same breed of cattle, the conditions in which they are raised can affect the quality of the meat.

American Wagyu is often raised in feedlots, where the cattle are confined and fed a high-calorie diet to encourage the development of marbling.

In contrast, Australian Wagyu is often raised in more open conditions, allowing the cattle to move around more freely and potentially leading to leaner meat. That being said, both types of meat can be of high-quality and offer a luxurious taste and texture.

What rank is Australian Wagyu? 

When it comes to ranking Wagyu beef, there are a few different systems in use. One common ranking system is the Beef Marbling Score (BMS), which rates the amount of intramuscular fat in the meat on a scale of 1 to 12. In Australia, Wagyu beef typically ranges from a BMS of 5 to 9, with some higher-end cuts reaching up to a BMS of 12. This places Australian Wagyu in the same range as other high-quality Wagyu beef from around the world.

To experience this remarkable quality, consider exploring The Meatery's selection of Australian Wagyu. Our Specialty Cuts - Beef collection features some of the highest-ranking marbling scores, providing an exceptional taste experience. Alternatively, if you're looking for a standout cut, try our 14 — 16 oz options, which showcase the rich, buttery texture and flavor that come with top-tier marbling. These premium choices reflect the high BMS ratings and ensure you enjoy the very best of Australian Wagyu.

Is Australian Wagyu the same as Japanese Wagyu

While Australian Wagyu and Japanese Wagyu both come from the same breed of cattle, there are some key differences to consider. Japanese Wagyu is often considered to be the gold standard of Wagyu beef– thanks to the rigorous standards and conditions in which the cattle are raised.

In Japan, Wagyu cattle are often raised in small herds and are fed a specialized diet that includes beer and other supplements, resulting in meat that is incredibly marbled and flavorful. In contrast, Australian Wagyu is often raised in larger herds and may not be fed the same specialized diet.

One thing to note is when it comes to price, Japanese Wagyu is often more expensive than Australian Wagyu. The strict diet and meticulous way of raising Wagyu cattle in Japan add to its expensive price tag.

How to cook Australian Wagyu 

If you've decided to splurge on some Australian Wagyu, it's important to know how to cook it properly to ensure that you get the most out of your investment. Because Wagyu beef is highly marbled and tender, it requires a slightly different cooking approach than other types of beef. Here are some tips for cooking Australian Wagyu to perfection:

  1. Let it come to room temperature: Take the beef out of the fridge about an hour before you plan to cook it, allowing it to come to room temperature. This will help it cook more evenly.
  2. Use low heat: Because Wagyu beef is so tender, it doesn't need a lot of heat to cook. Use low heat and cook the beef slowly to prevent overcooking or burning.
  3. Don't over-season: Because Australian Wagyu has a rich, buttery flavor, it doesn't need a lot of seasoning. A simple sprinkle of salt and pepper will do the trick.
  4. Use a meat thermometer: To ensure that your beef is cooked to the desired temperature, use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature. For rare beef, aim for an internal temperature of 125°F, while medium-rare beef should reach 130-135°F.
  5. Let it rest: After cooking, let the beef rest for a few minutes to allow the juices to redistribute. This will help ensure that your meat is juicy and flavorful.

How to Identify High-Quality Australian Wagyu

When searching for high-quality Australian Wagyu, there are several key factors to consider to ensure you're getting the best value for your money. Here’s a guide to help you identify top-notch Australian Wagyu:

1. Beef Marbling Score (BMS)

The Beef Marbling Score is crucial in assessing the quality of Wagyu beef. It measures the amount of intramuscular fat (marbling) present in the meat, which affects flavor, tenderness, and juiciness. Look for Australian Wagyu with a BMS of 5 or higher, as this indicates a significant level of marbling and premium quality.

2. Color and Texture

High-quality Wagyu should have a rich, reddish-pink color with a fine, even distribution of marbling throughout the meat. The texture should be smooth and silky, indicating a well-marbled cut. Avoid meat that appears too lean or has uneven marbling, as it may not deliver the signature Wagyu experience.

3. Fat Quality

The fat in Wagyu should be creamy white and well-distributed. High-quality Wagyu fat has a buttery texture and a lower melting point, contributing to the meat's rich flavor. If the fat is yellowish or has a coarse texture, it may not be of the highest quality.

4. Certification and Grading

Check for certification and grading labels from reputable Australian beef grading organizations. Authentic Australian Wagyu should come with proper documentation verifying its grade and origin. Look for labels from the Australian Wagyu Association or other recognized certifying bodies.

5. Source and Provenance

The source of the Wagyu can also impact its quality. Reputable producers and suppliers often have detailed information about their cattle’s lineage, diet, and raising conditions. Research the supplier or retailer to ensure they offer authentic Australian Wagyu and have a good reputation for quality.

6. Marble Density

Examine the density and distribution of the marbling. High-quality Australian Wagyu will have a consistent and dense marbling throughout the meat. This even distribution enhances the meat's flavor and tenderness, providing a luxurious eating experience.

By paying attention to these factors, you can confidently select high-quality Australian Wagyu that meets your standards and ensures a memorable culinary experience. Whether you're purchasing it for a special occasion or simply to enjoy at home, understanding these indicators will help you make an informed choice.

Final Thoughts: Try Your Favorite Australian Wagyu with The Meatery

While Australian Wagyu may not be the same as Japanese Wagyu, it is still a premium product that is worth the splurge for those who love the indulgent taste and texture of Wagyu beef.

With its unique qualities and high price tag, it's important to know what makes Australian Wagyu so special, how it compares to other premium meats, and how to cook it to perfection.

Whether you're enjoying it in a high-end restaurant or cooking it at home, Australian Wagyu is a luxurious and indulgent treat that is sure to satisfy your taste buds.

shop nick’s favorite cuts

Shop All