Is American Wagyu Worth the Price?

by Nicholas Fiorentino

PREP TIME

COOK TIME

YIELD

DIFFICULTY

Can Wagyu beef be raised in the US?

Yes, Wagyu beef can be successfully raised in the United States, and the industry has been growing steadily since the first Japanese Wagyu cattle were imported in the 1970s. American ranchers have adapted Japanese breeding and raising techniques while incorporating their own innovative practices to produce high-quality American Wagyu beef.

The success of American Wagyu production relies on several key factors:

Genetics: Pure Japanese Wagyu bloodlines are maintained through careful breeding programs
Environment: Specialized facilities and climate-controlled environments ensure optimal growing conditions
Diet: Custom feed programs rich in high-quality grains and forage
Care: Stress-free environments and individual attention to each animal

American Wagyu Beef producers (Such as Snake River Farms) primarily work with four main Wagyu breeds:

Japanese Black (Kuroge Washu)
Japanese Brown (Akaushi)
Japanese Polled
Japanese Shorthorn

Many U.S. ranchers have successfully adapted these breeds to American conditions while maintaining the essential qualities that make Wagyu beef exceptional. The American Wagyu Association helps maintain breeding standards and provides certification for authentic American Wagyu producers.

How close is American Wagyu to Japanese Wagyu?

American Wagyu represents a unique interpretation of Japanese Wagyu traditions, combining Japanese genetics with American cattle breeds and farming practices. While both products are exceptional, there are notable differences:

Genetic Composition: Most American Wagyu is a cross between Japanese Wagyu and high-quality American breeds like Angus
Marbling Patterns: Japanese Wagyu typically has more intense marbling
Flavor Profile: American Wagyu often offers a balanced blend of marbling and traditional beef flavor
Production Methods: American practices are adapted for larger-scale production while maintaining quality

While purebred Japanese Wagyu cattle exist in America, most American Wagyu is produced from crossbreeding programs that typically result in beef that's 50% to 93.75% Wagyu. This creates a product that combines the best characteristics of both Japanese Wagyu and American beef cattle.

The resulting meat offers exceptional quality while maintaining characteristics that appeal to American palates and cooking preferences.

The History of American Wagyu

The American Wagyu journey began in 1976 when the first Japanese Wagyu cattle were imported to the United States. This historical development occurred in several key phases:

1970s: Initial imports consisted of two Black Wagyu bulls, used primarily for research purposes at U.S. universities.

1980s: Four Japanese Black bulls were imported, marking the beginning of commercial Wagyu production in America. These bulls became the foundation for many modern American Wagyu breeding programs.

1990s: Additional imports of both female and male Wagyu cattle expanded the genetic pool. The American Wagyu Association was established in 1990 to maintain breed integrity and promote development.

Key milestones in American Wagyu development:

Establishment of crossbreeding programs with Angus cattle
Development of American-specific feeding protocols
Creation of grading standards for American Wagyu
Growth of domestic and export markets

Nutritional Comparison

American Wagyu beef offers a unique nutritional profile that sets it apart from both conventional beef and Japanese Wagyu:

Key Nutritional Characteristics:

Higher concentration of monounsaturated fats compared to regular beef
Rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
Higher levels of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)
Excellent source of essential vitamins and minerals

The unique fat composition of American Wagyu contributes to its health benefits while delivering the characteristic buttery texture and rich flavor.

Wagyu Grading System

American Wagyu uses a distinct grading system that combines elements from both Japanese and USDA grading standards:

American Wagyu Grades:

Gold Grade: Highest level, comparable to Japanese A4/A5
Silver Grade: Premium quality, exceeding USDA Prime (The Meatery's American Wagyu falls right in this category!)
Bronze Grade: Similar to high-end USDA Prime

Grading factors include:

Marbling score and quality
Meat color and brightness
Firmness and texture
Fat color and quality

The American Wagyu Association maintains these standards to ensure consistency and quality across the industry.

Is American Wagyu better than Prime?

American Wagyu consistently surpasses USDA Prime beef in several key aspects:

Superior Characteristics:

More extensive marbling patterns
Higher degree of tenderness
More complex flavor profile
Better fat quality and distribution

While USDA Prime represents the top 3% of American beef, American Wagyu exists in a category above this premium grade. The intense marbling and specialized breeding and raising techniques result in beef that offers superior eating qualities.

However, the comparison isn't strictly about "better" - it's about different characteristics and applications. Some dishes may actually be better suited to Prime beef, while others showcase the unique qualities of American Wagyu.